HomeDigital MarketingShould Youtube Ban Giveaways? - The Shortcut Success Mantra On Youtube

Should Youtube Ban Giveaways? – The Shortcut Success Mantra On Youtube


I watch many Youtube videos, and there are several creators that I admire. Not because they offer Giveaways, but because they create quality content.

In this article we will discuss the topic – Should Youtube Ban Giveaways? and what is the impact of Giveaways on thumbnail CTR, View Duration, SEO, and how it impacts a Channel growth and other creators.

Good Youtube Videos take effort and time to make. Also, you need to have skills in shooting videos, the right camera, audio, and lighting gear to make your message more appealing.

Should Youtube Ban Giveaways? - The Shortcut Success Mantra On Youtube

Also, you need a studio or space to shoot the videos to make them have the right vibe.

Not to mention, hours of editing before finally uploading the video to Youtube. It takes years for normal and honest creators to reach 500 thousand or a million subs on the platform.

But there are shortcuts to reach there fast. To understand these we need to first understand how the Youtube Algorithm works and how these shortcuts like giveaways impact the Youtube SEO.

YouTube Algorithm & SEO

There are several factors that make a video go viral and reach more audiences and the Algorithm starts promoting the video to peoples’ feed.

However, the most crucial factors for a video to get higher views are:

Thumbnail CTR (Click Through Rate)

If Youtube showed your video to 100 people in the feed, how many of them clicked on the thumbnail and watched your video. If 5 people click out of 100, then your CTR is 5%, and if 10 people click, then your CTR is 10%.

Average View Duration

Once someone clicks on the video and starts watching Youtube, measure how long he has watched the video. For example, if your video is 10 minutes long and someone watches it for 6 minutes, then the Average view duration is 6 minutes.

If 1000 people watch that video and the average view duration is high and protect your video to the end, that signals to Youtube Algorithm that it is interesting. The algorithm starts to promote it to people. The Algorithm enables it to people based on the topic of your video and their interests.

So now we understand the two metrics that are very crucial for Youtube success – CTR and the average view duration. Other factors that increase the reach and successor of a video are likes and comments.

How do Giveaways Impact the Video Reach and Success?

Let’s get to the point – The Giveaways impacts all of these parameters and SEO for YouTube Video. The users click more on videos that have Giveaway in the thumbnail or the title.

Further, the view duration and bounce rate decreases as the viewers are enticed to watch the full video to get to know about the giveaway and participate in it.

Also, the Youtubers usually ask to like, comment, and subscribe to the Channel, and it that also sends positive signals to the Youtube Algorithm to promote the video further.

So, by throwing money by doing Giveaways the Channel can gain 1000s of subscribers in a quick time and can also get lakhs of views that otherwise would not have been possible.

For small youtube creators who are starting out and creating quality content this is terrible.

As they are already struggling to keep the lights on whereas the bigger Youtubers using Giveaways as a means to create an undue advantage can keep crushing these smaller YouTubers.

Since the video gets a lot of views and the thumbnail has a higher CTR, the Youtube search results also feature it at the top, ahead of even better content from other creators.

All of this creates a terrible case for the viewers and other creators while the Youtuber who is throwing money to get an advantage is laughing and exploiting Youtube at its own game.

Several Examples of Giveaway Success Youtube Channels in Tech

Many Indian Tech YouTubers use this giveaway weapon very successfully and have amassed millions of subscribers and views.

They mostly tie-up with the brands for getting early review and giveaway units, and brands are also happy as they get eyeballs on the videos, and the creator only promotes the products and does giveaways.

These Youtubers are not doing actual product reviews, nor they mention that the video is sponsored by the brand. As per Youtube guidelines, if the Video has a paid promotion, the creator must disclose it. Nobody does that.

Poor viewers who think the Youtuber has millions of followers won’t be praising a bad product is trapped in all of this and end up buying bad quality products.

Should YouTube Ban Giveaways?

So, these Giveaways are not even suitable for the viewers who are getting low quality, paid, promotional content from brands. Hiding the truth and real cons about the devices they are selling in the market.

So my humble Appeal to readers is to not participate or watch such videos. Infact if you want to see better content on Youtube, you must dislike and unsubscribe from these paid channels.

Also, a humble request to Youtube to either ban this ugly giveaway culture or to at least put a limit to this draconian practice and hack that is hurting honest and true content creators in India.

Also, Read:

Kanuj has 12+ years of experience in Digitial Marketing, SEO, Social Media, Blogging, Wordpress, Analytics. He is an MBA in Marketing and Consumer Insights.Follow him on Twitter to get relevant advice.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here